#249 Moshe Hoffman: Problems With Theories In Psychology
Dr. Moshe Hoffman is a Research Scientist at MIT Media Lab & Lecturer at Harvard’s Department of Economics. He applies game theory, models of learning and evolution, and experimental methods, to try to decipher the (often subconscious and subtle) incentives that shape our social behavior, preferences, and ideologies. Dr. Hoffman obtained his Ph.D. in Economics from the University of Chicago, Booth School of Business and his B.S. in Economics from the University of Chicago. He also co-designed and teaches “Game Theory and Social Behavior” which lays out a lot of the evidence and models behind this approach.
In this episode, we talk about problems in how people come up with explanations to social phenomena in the social sciences, and more specifically, in social psychology. We discuss the levels of analysis through which we can study social phenomena, and why intuitive explanations don’t work. We also refer to perverse incentives in the social sciences. Dr. Hoffman then talks about the example of cognitive dissonance, and the correct interpretation of the phenomenon. In the latter part of the interview, we discuss the aspects of (social) behavior that evolutionary psychology explains well, and where it fails or is not enough.
Time Links:
Issues with how people study social phenomena (particularly in social psychology)
Levels of analysis for studying behavioral/social phenomena
The problem with explanations in social psychology
Why intuitive explanations don’t work
Perverse incentives in the social sciences
The example of cognitive dissonance
Why we can’t change people’s thinking and behavior with facts
The interplay between evolutionary psychology and game theory
Cultural traditions (and the example of the use of spices in food)
Applying evolutionary psychology to understand social incentives
Critique to Steven Pinker’s take on “moral progress”
Follow Dr. Hoffman’s work!
Follow Dr. Hoffman’s work:
Faculty page: https://tinyurl.com/y7g2ubal
Personal website: https://tinyurl.com/yboyxvxu
Articles on Researchgate: https://tinyurl.com/ybxwknfs
Twitter handle: @Moshe_Hoffman
The Twitter threads:
“The problems w/ “theories” in psychology.”: http://bit.ly/30hRgt6
“Best criticism of social-psychology I have seen”: http://bit.ly/30jBY6W
“Some thoughts on how to spot bull-shit in science/academia”: http://bit.ly/2KNRdys
“A good theory should”: http://bit.ly/2NiMMyA
“Why do I think our preferences and ideologies respond to incentives?”: http://bit.ly/31O3h9R
“A thread clarifying my criticism of Evolutionary Psychology”: http://bit.ly/31H8xfA
“Why do people have ridiculous beliefs?”: http://bit.ly/30mhb2M