#142 James Tabery: The Nature-Nurture Debate, And Its Ethics
Dr. James Tabery is Adjunct Associate Professor of Pediatrics, Adjunct Associate Professor of Internal Medicine and Associate Professor of Philosophy at the University of Utah. His research focuses largely on the philosophy of science and applied ethics, as well as the intersection between those domains. On the philosophy of science side, he investigates questions of causation and explanation in biology; while on the applied ethics side, he explores how the answers to those questions have ethical, legal, and social implications. He’s also the author of the book Beyond Versus: The Struggle to Understand the Interaction of Nature and Nurture.
In this episode, we focus on some of the main topics of Dr. Tabery’s book, Beyond Versus. We go through the historical origins of the nature-nurture debate, and the early stages of Biology, and the influences of genetics and the study of development. Then, we address the complexity of the interaction between genes and the environment, and how they mediate each other’s effects on the organism. And we finish up with a couple of questions about the ethical implications of this science, including the dangers of focusing too much on nature, or believing in extreme environmentalism and views of the mind as a blank slate, and also the technical and ethical limitations to gene editing, human enhancement and eugenics.
Time Links:
The origins of the nature-nurture debate
Genetics and the eugenics movement
The introduction of development in Biology, and the nurture side
Are environmental effects always mediated by genetics?
Is it easier to identify genetic factors than environmental ones?
The trouble with the complexity of genetics, and pleiotropic effects
Are there any situations where the environment is the single cause?
Gene-environment correlations, and people creating their own environments
How to correctly frame the nature-nurture debate
The ethical dangers of focusing too much on nature
Sometimes, social justice is made on the basis of the innateness of certain traits
Also, the dangers of extreme environmentalism
On eliminating “negative” traits, and human enhancement
Follow Dr. Tabery’s work!
Follow Dr. Tabery’s work:
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy’s entrances on genetics: https://tinyurl.com/y7qnpled
Faculty page: https://tinyurl.com/yde5znvp
Beyond Versus: https://tinyurl.com/ya9af47a